Stanislav Govorukhin film "The End of a Beautiful Era": reviews da kuma bayanin

A fim "The End of a Beautiful Era", reviews na wanda za mu tattauna a wannan talifin, ya zo ga babban allo a 2015. Ta magoya an jiran wani sosai sanannen marubuci Sergei Dovlatov, kamar yadda daya daga cikin tarin da ya gajejjeran labaru, ya ba da dalilin rubutun da tef, kuma shi ne na farko film karbuwa daga cikin marubuci ta aiki.

"A karshen wani babban zamanin": sukar, da ra'ayin yin wani fim

Soviet cinema masoya ba zai zama da wuya a tuna wanda shi ne mutumin da a baya irin wannan wurin hutawa Rasha fina-finan a matsayin "Voroshilov Sharpshooter" da kuma "The wuri ba za a iya canja." Hakika, a gane master of shugabanci - Stanislav Govorukhin. "A karshen wani babban zamanin", reviews na wanda aka bar matsayin sana'a sukar, da kuma talakawa moviegoers, shi ne daya daga cikin na karshe ayyukansu na babban darektan. Shi ne ya kamata a lura da cewa a lokacin da aiki a cikin fim Maestro ya riga ya juya shekaru 80 da haihuwa, amma cewa bai hana shi rayayye kãma na darektan aikin da cikakken shiga a cikin yin fim.

Mawallafi, wanda tarin gajejjeran labaru, "Jayayya" ya ba da dalilin rubutun ga fim, shi ya zama sananne Sergei Dovlatov. "A karshen wani babban zamanin", reviews na wanda sukan rage ga kwatanta da tef da a baya aka buga litattafan, bai zama cikakken allo version na labarin.

"Jayayya", tare da tamkar film

A lokacin, ya ga gaci taron Dovlatov mabiyin magoya na da basira domin ya rubuta a cikin wani sosai musamman, muhimmi a cikin shi kadai hanya. Wannan ya rayu a cikin Tarayyar Soviet da kuma rubuta da na kewaye da shi: ga Soviet gwamnati, talakawa mutane, siyasa da kuma katsalandan. Ya rubuta sosai neatly, daidai, da kuma a cikin dukan ayyukansa akwai wani m dabara ci mutumci da kuma irony da kuma wani lokacin har sarcasm. A tsawon lokaci, wannan irin ayyukan Dovlatov suka tsananta da hukumomi na Soviets, kuma marubucin da aka tilasta su yi hijira zuwa {asar Amirka. Akwai ya quite nasarar da aka buga, da aka buga a cikin sosai girmamawa American wallafe, kuma ma ya jagoranci kansa marubucin shirin a kan iska na "Radio Liberty".

A tarihin "jayayya"

A kawai 'yan shekaru kafin hijira zuwa biography na Dovlatov shi ne a lokacin da ya rayu a Estonia. Da farko Dovlatov yi aiki a matsayin mai zaman kansa labaru a cikin Editorial ofishin na "Soviet Estonia", da kuma a shekara ta 1972 aka kwantar da wani dan jarida a bayanai sashen na jaridar.

Own kwarewa a wallafe-wallafe, kuma ya ba da dalilin rubuta labarun tattara a "jayayya".

The tarin kunshi 12 labaru cewa suna da alaka da juna guda mãkirci: su magana game da aikin wani mai talented matasa marubuci, kuma a cikin gida jaridu. Duk da cewa littafin da aka fili autobiographical, da yawa, ciki har da sanannen Rasha marubuci kuma marubuci Valery Popov, ba quite fahimci dovlatovskogo irony da sarcasm game da Editorial mores na lokaci. A cewar Popov, Sergei Donatovich lokaci na aiki a cikin "Soviet Estonia" ya sosai hayayyafa domin marubucin, kuma a cikin wording na ta girmamawa da kuma mai daraja a matsayin m jarida da kuma wani talented marubuci.

m farkon

A fim "The End of a Beautiful Era", wanda sake bitar sau da yawa yabo ne takamaiman asalin a cikin nau'i na tarihin Tarayyar Soviet, farko a cikin jerin baki-da-fari shirin batutuwa. Sun nuna ainihin harbi Yuriya Gagarina bayan da ya yi na almara sarari jirgin. Game nuna a piano baiwa Van Kliberna, isa a m Elizabeth Taylor Union. Documentary harbi daidai da realistically ake bayyana yanayi a cikin majami'ar da na Soviet, a lõkacin da waqe-waqe daga mataki da kuma karanta Okudjava Ahmadulina, kazalika da yanayi na masu sauraro a lokacin da ya rera waka da songs Vysotsky. Nikita Khrushchev a kan frame jihohin da duk wanda ya saba da manufofin da kungiyar tarayyar a cikin kungiyar tarayyar ba ya rike da fiye da yake da cikakken goyon baya da kuma wani flurry na motsin zuciyarmu duk yarda da wannan manufofin.

Wadannan maki suna sosai a fili da kuma realistically nuna halayya cewa rinjaye a cikin Tarayyar Soviet a cikin tsakiyar da kuma marigayi '60s, ga mazansu, a muhallinsa kuma yana nuna a farkon fim "The End of Belle Epoque." Reviews na movie na mutane suka halarta events nuna, suka ce abin da yake mai kyau bayani Govorukhin ba su da damar gaske tuna yana saurayi, samartaka, yara. Ganin wadannan Shots, da yawa yana sa kadan ji na nostalgia na lokaci.

mãkirci summary

"The End of a Beautiful Era" (martani wanda sau da yawa zarga da rauni storyline) ne game da wani matashi marubuci Andre Lentulova. Littafan, kamar yadda, lalle ne, da kuma da yawa marubuta matasa, ba a buga a kafofin watsa labarai, don haka ya sami wani amfani a gare da basira, wanda shi ne iya ciyar da yaro. Saurayi aiki a matsayin 'yar jarida da jaridar, amma saboda ya kishi da kuma gaban katsalandan ba zai iya rike fita for dogon a wuri guda.

Wata rana, quite da hatsari, ya miƙa zuwa Tallinn da kuma yin aiki a wani gida jarida, abin da Andrew ya amince ba shakka dogon. Amma a lokacin da ya koma Estonia, ya gane cewa gida farfaganda da kuma yin katsalandan kada ka bi a tsakiyar, daga abin da ya na kokarin barin.

Kamance da kuma bambance-bambance tsakanin littattafai da kuma fina-finai al'amuran

"The End of a Beautiful Era" (reviews na movie ba mafi m, ayan bar mabiyin Raya Makon Dovlatov) ya nuna kawai 'yan aukuwa na "jayayya". Stanislav sallami events aka bayyana a cikin littafin, shekaru da dama, da kuma quite sana'a ya sanya ta akida da girmamawa a cikin labarin. Mai sukar sun dauka shi ne quite al'ada, kamar yadda kowane darektan yana da cikakken iko a nasu hanyar fassara da aikin na marubucin.

"A karshen wani babban zamanin" - wani fim Govorukhin, reviews na wanda Dovlatova magoya barin ne ba ko da yaushe warmest, mafi m kunya wadanda suka zabi to watch shi kawai saboda da cewa shi aka yin fim a kan tushen da wani "jayayya". Mafi yawan wadanda suka ga tef, cewa daga shi ya Dovlatov kawai bace. Ya dabara irony bayyana ba duk, a matsayin protagonist, wanda ya zama samfur na marubucin, kawai ta atomatik Kalmar rubutu rubuta da babban Sergei Donatovich, kuma ba sosai kallon fage da kuma aka hannu a cikin mãkirci, amma kawai ba a can.

Actors da matsayin

A fim "The End of a Beautiful Era" Reviews "Imhonet" wanda aka sau da yawa rage zuwa tattaunawa na aiki da shi, ya tara aka riga aka sani, kuma ƙaunar da masu sauraro da 'yan wasan kwaikwayo a kan sa. A cikin harbe-harbe a dauki bangare Sergei Garmash, Dmitry Astrakhan da Fedor Dobronravov. Bayan 'yan mashahuri sunayen a cikin fim buga da' yan wasan kwaikwayo wanda ba tukuna da high sani daga wani m masu sauraro. Kamar yadda irin wannan za a iya gani a matsayin Ivan Kolesnikov, Lentulova alamar tauraro a cikin fim "The End of Belle Epoque." Reviews sukar aikinsa ne quite rigima.

Kwaikwayo game da aiki aiki na namiji gubar

A daya hannun, da yawa ce cewa Kolesnikov ya iya samu nasarar ratsa allon dovlatovskogo m hani da sanyi stoicism.

Amma, a daya hannun, da yawa sukar rubuta cewa actor har yanzu doke: wani lokacin halinsa alama a bit lethargic, kuma ga alama cewa ba shi ne wani aiki takara a abubuwan da suka faru, amma kawai kallon daga fage.

Ƙimar na aikin Svetlany Hodchenkovoy

Da muhimmancin da Marina, shugaban edita na Tallinn jarida, ya tafi zuwa ga actress, wanda ke taka a cikin aikin Govorukhin ta ba da farko, - Svetlana Khodchenkova. A cikin labarin, ta daura wa protagonist ne sosai m, kuma m dangantaka da yake da wuya ga sanyã wa format na wani misali ofishin romance. Age na heroine, buga da Hodchenkova, yana sa ta ta tunani game da su a nan gaba da kuma haihuwar yara. Lentulov amma ba cikin sauri yi mata aure shawara, damar kansa to ku ciyar lokaci a cikin sauna da wani matashi fan of da basira a matsayin marubuci, amma kuma da sosai Marina ne ba cikin sauri zuwa bari tafi.

Reviews sukar game da actor ta aiki a wannan tef Svetlana ƙara samu tabbatacce. Ta ya iya daidai wasa irin image na Snow Sarauniya, da kuma nuna da bala'i na mace ta rayuwa tare da babban hani.

Sergei Garmash, kamar yadda ko da yaushe, ya yi wani babban aiki tare da rawa, shi zai ze, na biyu da shirin. Amma a gaskiya, ya jami'in 'yan sanda, ya bayyana ne kawai a cikin' yan aukuwa, abubuwan da ya nuna daya daga cikin manyan ra'ayoyin da fim: duk mutanen da ke kewaye da yawa magana game da rashin 'yanci, amma idan ka ba su wannan' yanci, abu ne mai wuya, za su fahimci cewa ya zama wajibi a yi shi .

Game da wasan ne actor na masu sauraro wanda ya duba hoton sau da yawa ya zauna mai kyau ra'ayi.

A fim "The End of a Beautiful Era": reviews, reviews

A saki wannan tef a kan allo gaugawa jiran musamman magoya Stanislava Govoruhina, ga abin da ya unshakable gunki a shiryarwa ba.

A fim "The End of a Beautiful Era", sake bitar mere kallo na wanda za mu tattauna a kara daki-daki a cikin wannan labarin, an yi musu da gaske sa ran. Mutane da yawa rubuta bayan kallon cewa movie juya daga cikin nasu irin. Duk da cewa fim ya nuna ƙarshen "Belle Epoque", watau na tsawon Soviet rayuwa, wadda ta zo bayan da almara narke, ya nuna wani mai idon basira hoto na yau da kullum sha na Soviet 'yan ƙasa da kuma tartsatsi katsalandan, wanda wani lokacin musanta kowa hankali da kuma zo a cikin m. Duk da haka, fim F ba sa overt negativity.

Bayan kallon yawancin masu kallo mazan, a akasin haka, a ji na nostalgia for baya siga.

M magoya directed da wani daga cikin sabon aiki riskarsa kamar gida da bude kofa fitacciyar. Domin irin wannan mabiyin magoya ba zai iya zama wani togiya da kuma kafin mu wani fim Stanislava Govoruhina - "The karshen wani babban zamanin." Responses game da shi Raya Makon da darektan, ba shakka, ko da yaushe bar mafi cewa ba shi ne mafi kyau. Amma akwai ba su yarda da ra'ayinsu.

A fim "The End of a Beautiful Era" (ratings kuma sake dubawa a kan abin da akwai wani lokacin sosai shubuha) ne sau da yawa soki dõmin karkatarwa da wasu daga cikin real facts. A daya hannun, da fim fara da jerin Documentaries da cewa bunkasa sakamako na hakikanci na abin da ke faruwa a kan labarin a kan. Amma a daya bangaren, da yawa shaidu na abubuwan da suka faru da aka nuna a cikin fim, ya ce cewa ba duk abin da a da shi ne suka riwaito ba kai domin ba. Sau da yawa da shi tattauna episode cikin abin da aka nuna yadda Amirkawa na farko ya sauka a kan wata, da kuma duk Soviet kafofin watsa labarai boye wannan al'amari. A cikin fim, ganin game da wannan rahoton, da heroes yi kama da Finnish tashoshi. Korau sake dubawa game da wannan episode bar ga mutãne waɗanda suke tunãwa wadanda sau. Suka ce cewa a gaskiya da bayanai Soviet hukuma taba boye, da matasa wanda ganin wannan fim, kuma zai yarda da shi a matsayin gaskiya, saboda irin wannan murdiya na tarihi facts iya samun daidai ba ra'ayi game da wannan "Belle Epoque."

An shi daraja jawabin lokaci browsing?

Idan akwai free lokaci, fim ne har yanzu daraja a look, kamar yadda "The End of a Beautiful Era", reviews, da kuma sake dubawa na sana'a sukar game da abin da akwai wani lokacin diametrically daban-daban, koyar da kallo - duk da cewa a rayuwar sau da yawa da daidaitawa, shi ne ba sa na sake akida, da kuma canza nasu ra'ayi, karkiyar daga cikin yanayi.