A littafin da kuma play "binne ni ga skirting": shedu. "Binne ni ga skirting-2" ( "The tarihin gouging"): feedback daga masu karatu da kuma masu sukar

Ta yaya duniya a idanun yaron, wanda shi ne batu na iyali feuds? The yaro jin da Loneliness, zafi, da kuma wani lokacin laifi. Duk wannan sanya wani nauyi dutse a kan zuciyarsa da kuma ba ya tafi gaba daya. Wannan shi ne yara da darektan, actor kuma screenwriter Paul Sanaeva. A farkon aikin art, ya bar game da kwarewa feedback. "Binne ni a baya da Baseboard" - ba a tarihin ko tunãwa, amma wani ƙoƙari na gafarta masõyansa ga zafi cewa sun sa shi ya son, da kuma rauni, son kai da kuma selflessness.

prehistory

Paul Sanaev - gaje aiki daular. A shida sa, ya taka muhimmiyar rawa a cikin fim na uban rana Rolan Bykov "Scarecrow." A fim da aka sadaukar da rikitarwa dangantaka tsakanin matasa. A wannan hoton, Paul mahaifiyar taka rawar da wani malamin makaranta. Domin da novice actor halarci yin fim na Rolan Bykov ya ba kawai farkon wani m hanya, amma kuma su gano da kewaye zaman duniya. Kafin na farko bayyanar a kan sa na Paul samu wani m karancin sadarwa. Gaskiyar cewa yaron farko shekaru ransa aka kare ba kawai daga sadarwa tare da takwarorinsu, amma ko da ya bukatar wani mahaifiyarsa soyayya.

Yadda ya yi da littafin

A makarantar sakandare, Paul ya fara haifar da wasu almara almara. Da ya rubuta Bayan haka, gyara, da kuma kawai shekaru takwas daga baya ya shirya don kammala kayan zane, wanda aka kira "binne ni karkashin Plinth".

Reviews na littafin sun kasance duka biyu tabbatacce kuma korau. Wasu yi imani da cewa labarin Sanaeva - nishadi aiki, ba bã tãre da baki mutumci. Wasu ga m da sosai m hanya, marubucin sha'awar saka uwa ga raunin da ya sa. Wasu da dukan zuciyata dski yaron, wanda yake a cikin irin wannan deplorable yanayi.

Duk da cewa littafin ya wakilci iyaye Eleny Sanaevoy, cewa shi ne - da iyali kakaninki marubucin na sa mamaki littafin, shi ya kamata a tuna da cewa shi ne, ba wani shirin amma a aiki na art aka wani labari "binne ni karkashin Plinth". Reviews na littafin, kamar yadda marubucin da marmarin bakanta yan uwa, iya wuya a kira haƙiƙa. Names of masõyansa da marubuci ya canja. A protagonist kira Sasha Saveliev. Uwar - Olga. A uban rana da kuma basu da wani sunan. Kakaninki kira shi ba kamar yadda daban-daban a matsayin Dwarf-bloodsucker.

Hoton na kaka

Sanaev rubuta wani littafi, wanda aiki a matsayin abu don kansa kwarewa. Hoton na da babban harafin - wani eccentric da unbalanced kaka - dauka daga rayuwa, amma suna goyon bayan da abubuwa na almarar. Wannan mace da aka tsoro da wani takwas shekara Sasha ya da kauna da iyaka kula, kuma ya karshe zo ga ƙarshe cewa shi zai sãme shi mutuwa, amma saboda ya yi ba zato ba tsammani da ra'ayin cewa wajibi ne a bar wani kananan amma bayyananne wasiya, a cikin abin da kawai ake bukata shi ne "binne ni karkashin Plinth ".

Reviews na littafin, wanda aka rubuta da jikan, Vsevolod da Lydia Sanaeva sun bar, saboda duk ya mutu kafin shi da aka buga. Artwork ƙare kaka ta mutuwa. A hakikanin rai, Lydia Sanaeva mutu 'yan shekaru kafin littafin na littafin ta jikan. Marubucin kansa da zarar yarda cewa ya iya taba buga littafinsa a ta rayuwa.

Lydia Sanaeva

Labarin zai fara tare da sura "Bathing." Mai karatu daga na farko Lines fahimci cewa littafin da aka kishin ba irin da m kaka. Ko da yake damuwa shi ne ya jikan ba a rage su ba. Cikin dukanin labarin to ya jikan kaka predicts matsala, ya so ya "rot a kurkuku" da kuma annabta sauri m mutuwa. La'ana, kuma la'ana da mace ce, ba neman up daga yin ya bi. Yana shirya Sasha abin da ake ci karin kumallo, shirya domin shi ya wanka hadaddun hanyoyin stuffs Allunan. A general, yi duk abin da ya yaron ya mutu ba sai da wuri, kamar yadda idan tana son ta ...

Kuma a cikin littafin, da kuma a wata hira da marubucin labarin ya yi iƙirari cewa, a da shi ya dage farawa daga ba ƙashin gaskiya game da farkon shekara. Labari Kaka gaske ya zaɓi magana ne yafi stringent. Amma don samar da irin wannan unsightly bayani bai sa hankali. Bayan duk, shi ne littafin da ba a game da ciwon hauka, da soyayya da ya kashe, maims, haddasa kafu daram wani tunanin rauni.

Kaka jikan kullum ya tuna min da cewa ya bar su rayu quite a bit. Ko da yake a wajenka, cikin soyayya da shi. Regular magana game da rashin lafiya da kuma mutuwa na iya tasiri ga ji na duniya. Sasha, duk da ya matasa shekaru, ya fara tunanin mutuwa a matsayin wani abu quite talakawa. Kuma, ba shakka, ba zai iya tunanin cewa halayyar daga cikin mafi kusa mutum a cikin rayuwarsa shi ne ɗan daban-daban daga cikin misali muhimmi wajen tunani da lafiya mutum.

zargi

A cikin marigayi nineties Pavlu Sanaevu ya iya buga aikinsa a wallafe-wallafen mujallar. Kawai a 2003 ya bayyana labari "binne ni karkashin Plinth" a raba ɗaba'ar. Reviews na littafin da aka bambanta. A Yara tunanin ba mutumci da kuma bakin ciki. Suna iya so, kuma zai iya zama ya fusata. Amma gaskiyar cewa littafin halitta mai talented mutum iya wuya a yi shakka.

fim

A shekara ta 2009 an fim labari "binne ni karkashin Plinth". Reviews na movie Sanaev bar musamman korau. A fim marubucin daba littafin bai so, na farko, saboda actress wanda ya taka leda da gubar mace rawa bai jimre da aiki. Wannan, ba shakka, da darektan ruwan inabi. Svetlana Kryuchkov - fice Soviet da kuma Rasha actress - buga da kaka a kan wani guda rubutu. Duk wanda ya karanta samfurin, ba zai iya taimaka amma shigar da cewa ƙirƙirar allo image yana da kadan da ya yi tare da wallafe-wallafe. The sosai guda actress ce a cikin wata hira da cewa da yawa muhimmanci al'amuran da aka yanka a nema daga cikin fim m.

A kan rawar da Lidii Sanaevoy asali shirya ya dauki 'yarta. Amma bayan marubucin labarin da rubutun ƙi yin aiki, duk abin da ya canza. Babban rawa aka gayyace wani actress. Daga baya Elena Sanaeva gane cewa shi zai zama unbearably wuya a yi wasa nasa mahaifiyarsa.

Vsevolod Sanaev

Grandpa Sasha Savelyev - mai laushi mutumin a cikin dukan baya ga matarsa. Its samfur ne Vsevolod Sanaev - Soviet actor, da aka sani ga fina-finan "Domin mu Moscow", "The Return of St. Luka", "Manta Melody for sarewa" da sauransu.

Sasha ta mahaifin uwar taka muhimmiyar rawa a cikin labarin "binne ni karkashin Plinth". Sharhi kan Paul Sanaeva film ne dan kadan daban-daban daga cikin ra'ayoyi na masu sauraro da kuma masu sukar game da wannan littafin. Duk wanda ya karanta autobiographical labari Sanaeva yawanci huska kan gane hoto Sergei Snezhkin. Amma kakan babban harafin a cikin fim buga wani shahararren actor Alexey Petrenko. Kuma da image cewa ya halitta a kan allo, watakila, ba na baya zuwa da wallafe-wallafen.

Shi ne ta hanyar wannan hali da marubuci ya iya nuna ikon yinsa, na zãlunci da ƙẽtare hauka kaka. Mafi yawa daga cikin ayyukan da kishin siffar dangantaka da kuma rayuwa a cikin gidan, wanda shi ne gida Sasha. Kuma idan fashewa da zãlunci da bai dace ba hali kaka yaro ba zai iya hana saboda su shekaru, da cewa mijinta yana rubuce iya shi. Amma ya zauna shiru, mafi, to Curry ni'imar da ita, yin biyayya cika dukan bukatun. Kuma kadai lokaci ya fashe fita daga gidan. Don 'yan sa'o'i don dawo sake. Domestic zaluncin, ya ba su iya shawo kan. Yana ba da ƙarfi da kuma juriyarsu, da kuma mahaifiyar protagonist.

Lokacin da yake karanta labarin, da kaka, duk da dukan da baƙuncin, shi ne mai tausayi. Tashin hankalin shi ne ba kawai wani shafi tunanin mutum da cuta, amma kuma da rashin tunani da mijinta, wanda a da ƙaramin shekaru da aka ba su biya ba isa hankali ga matarsa. Ta guda-handedly ya yi yaƙi domin rayuwar da farko yaro. Amma yaron ya mutu 'yan shekaru baya da aka haife Olga - uwar Sasha - da yarinya mai raɗaɗi, kuma m. Uba ƙara fakowa ba daga yawon shakatawa, a m tafiye-tafiye. Ya bai lura cewa matarsa da aka juya a cikin wani hysterical tsofaffi mace.

Elena Sanaeva

Wannan ne samfur na actress Olga - Sasha ta uwa. Elena Sanaeva Soviet lokaci, yara da farko tunawa da aikin ta a matsayin Alice a Fox fim, a cikin abin da ta taka rawar da wani aljanna-labari a wani Duet tare da mijinta.

Olga ta image ne wanda aka nuna da taimakon ciki abubuwan da yaron a cikin labarin "binne ni karkashin Plinth". A littafin, game da abin da masu sukar sau da yawa mayar da hankali a kan kyakkyawar m style of marubucin, to date, ba a mayalwaci yin fim.

A cikin fim mai ba da umarni Sergei Snezhkin uwa Sasha, domin ba a sani ba dalilai, shi ne mafi reminiscent na wani rauni depressive mace wanda, maimakon ciwon don yin yaki domin ɗansa, sha brandy tare da ita lover. Sa'an nan tururi rushes rawa. Amincewar ne yafi heroine Svetlany Kryuchkovoy. Ko da yake ta hysterical kururuwarta da peculiar la'ana. shi ya nuna, albeit wajen wani irin, kula game da yaron.

Abin da ya ke tunani game da movie Paul kansa Sanaev? "Binne ni ga skirting", reviews na wanda su ne musamman m, ya an soki marubucin labarin. Da farko an zaci cewa darektan fina-finai da kanta za matsayi. Amma a karshe lokacin da na ki yarda marubucin na aikin, saboda yana tabbata ba ya iya ba da halittar zanen sosai kokarin, nawa aka kashe a rubuta wani littafi. A kera ya sami wani darektan. Suka zama Sergey Snezhkin, wanda ra'ayi shi ne a rashin daidaito da matsayi na marubucin na script, ba kawai game da simintin. Snezhkin muhimmanci canza da kuma mãkirci.

A fim scripted Sanaeva ban mamaki 'yan wasan kwaikwayo da hannu. Amma ko da su talented wasan ba zai ajiye hoto cewa marubucin labari kira "seamy gefe". A cikin fim, akwai naturalistic cikakken bayani, wadda bisa ga sukar, superfluous. Kuma mafi muhimmanci, ba a bi da babban ra'ayin na Paul Sanaeva. Hoton na da kaka a cikin fim ne ma shubuha.

Me suka tunani game da wani karbuwa daga Sanaeva wasa da babban matsayin a cikin film "binne ni a baya da Baseboard"? Reviews na movie 'yan wasan kwaikwayo dabam- dabam suke. Jagoranci lady ikirarin cewa ta kama da aka muhimmanci canja a sakamakon da kafuwa. Maria Shukshin, wanda ya taka leda uwar Sasha, ya kwaikwayo na yin fim na movie da aka kada ku rarraba. Duk da haka, mafi yawan masu sauraro zaton zabi na darektan domin amfanin da actress ya ba da mafi kyau.

Dwarf-bloodsucker

Wannan hali ne kusan ba ba a cikin littafin, amma har yanzu yana tsakiyar. Shi ne saboda Dwarf-bloodsucker uwa bar danta. Kuma shi ne saboda wani rashin lafiya tsõhuwa aka tilasta shayar da mama m "Rotting" yaron. A kalla a cikin farkon shekaru tabbatar jikan kaka, makangari. Amma Sasha ya taba gani da mummunan Dwarf, da kuma samu a cikin shi kome m.

Ta uban rana, darektan da actor Rolan Bykov sadaukar Paul Sanaev labari "binne ni karkashin Plinth". Masu sukar wannan aikin wani lokacin, watakila, ba m. Yana ba ya yiwuwa ga wani mutum na Celebrity iyali ya wanke datti lilin a jama'a. Amma siffar ta uban rana, wanda daga baya ya juya ga zama ba yana nufin tsanani, marubucin wanda aka nuna da wani kwarjinin da kuma soyayya. Mai hikima, talented da kuma fahimtar Sanaev aka bayyana shi a cikin ta farko labari. A wannan marubuci ya nuna masa uban rana a cikin kayan zane a kan misadventures na gouging. A littafin "binne ni a baya da Baseboard - 2", wanda sake dubawa kasance ba haka ba mai karko, amma da dauki rightful wuri a cikin zamani wallafe-wallafe.

"Binne ni a baya da Baseboard" (yi)

Reviews na wasan kwaikwayo da kuma film karbuwa daga cikin mafi kowa korau. Wannan ba abin mamaki bane. Bazawa na littafin Sanaeva zama abin mamaki a cikin wallafe-wallafen duniya. Kuma da ya fi girma da rawa Yanã shigar da littafin, da more hankali binciki zargi da marubucin mãkirci jiki a kan mataki ko a kan allo. Directed by Igor Konyayeva, wanda premiered a shekarar 2007 a cikin wasan kwaikwayo "Baltic House", da rawar da yaro taka leda fiye da wani balagagge actor, Igor Sklyar. Game da wasan kwaikwayon da sukar amsa farincikin nisa. Masu kallo staging kagaggun son. An saka tauraro ya karbi mafi Theatrical kyauta "Golden Sofit".

Ba kawai Igor Konyayeva wahayi zuwa mãkirci labarin "binne ni karkashin Plinth". Reviews daga cikin play (Krasnoyarsk) Alexei sau da yawa zargi approving, wanda ba shine darektan na St. Petersburg productions, kuma ko da more game da fim karbuwa da Sergey Snezhkin shugabanci. Babban jigo na ayyukan Pavla Sanaeva shi ne soyayya, da wata gãfara.

Naturalistic cikakkun bayanai da kuma cin nãman kaka ba ta da marubucin da labarin daidai kamar yadda ya cancanta. Babban ra'ayin da marubuci ya iya kawo Aleksey Kriklivy a kan mataki Krasnoyarsk Theater. Kaka - ba wani abin ƙi dodo, kuma tir da m mutum. Wannan mace duk rayuwata neman soyayya, amma ba zai iya gaske yarda da godiya. Sanarwar fili ya nuna zargi rayuwa, akwai mutane da yawa kananan abubuwa da suke sauƙi recognizable ƙarnõni na masu kallo, wanda ke da mulkin Paul Sanaev: T-shirt da alama na Olympic bear, yara fina-finai, songs na eighties, da rare game da wukake.

Yadda za a amsa ga littafin prototypes na leoyan?

Samar da farko aikin na almarar, Paul Sanaev babu shakka nasara. Kuma ko da bayan na farko wallafa aikinsa da aka ƙi, ba damu. Next zuwa gare shi su ne mafi m bita - mahaifiyarsa da uban rana. Rolan Bykov son wannan labarin. A Elena Sanaeva ta yi karfi ra'ayi. A wata hira, sai ya ce Sana mahaifiyar mafi sa samun abinci dandana karanta na karshe babi, abin da ya bayyana kakarta ta jana'iza.

tsawo

A 'yan shekaru bayan buga na farko da littafin, Sanaa fara rubuta "binne ni ga skirting-2." Reviews na aikin da wannan marubucin ya bar wa mai karatu da ya fi aiki na da ƙarni na eighties. Sanaeva ayyukan ba da damar nitse a cikin gabata. Kuma ko da waɗanda suka yi girma har a wani yanayi na soyayya da kuma fahimtar, ya littattafai ba zai iya zama sha'aninsu dabam. Sanaev masterfully ake bayyana rayuwar halin da ake ciki da cewa rinjãya a waɗannan kwanaki kusan kowane gida.

"A tarihin gouging" ba sun hada da mai yawa psychologically nauyi al'amuran, abin da, misali, da monologue ne a kaka a farkon labarin. Amma a cikin wannan aiki, ably canjawa wuri zuwa sararin sama, wanda sun girma da waɗanda suke a yanzu game da arba'in. Nostalgia for yara da kuma faruwa da - abin da farko janyo hankalin masu karatu a cikin wannan littafi.