Larisa Ogudalova da Katerina Kabanova: kwatanta irin abubuwan da

Katerina da Larissa Ogudalova - babban harafin biyu shahara plays A. N. Ostrovskogo, "The Storm" (1859) da kuma "Bride" (1878). Works rabu goma sha tara shekara, amma za ka iya samun mai yawa da ya yi a wadannan wasanin kwaikwayo.

Biyu heroines - mai kama da rabo

A mataki faruwa a cikin wani karamin lardin gari a cikin m-bourgeois yanayi, da sakandare haruffa - wakilan da ake kira Uku Estate. Wasanni na rayuwar yau da kullum ne tsakiya zuwa mãkirci hidima a matsayin bango ga jaddadawa da kuma ci gaban da hotuna na 'yan wasa, kazalika da samar da wani kaifi bambanci tsakanin Larissa Ogudalovoy da Catherine a hannu daya kuma da kewaye yanayi - a kan sauran. Faye hali da kuma kwatanta Larissa Ogudalovoy heroine da Caterina Kabanovoy ne batu na wannan rahoto.

Common siffofin a cikin hali na Larissa da Catherine

Images of haruffan da yawa a cikin na kowa. A 'yan mata bai dace a cikin m-tausayin-bourgeois duniya, duk da cewa su aka haife, girma da kuma masu ilimi ne a gare shi. Dukansu mafarki na 'yanci da farin ciki soyayya da kuma karfi da hamayya da dokoki, dokoki da halaye da aka gudanar da su a iyali, abokai da kuma, a karshe, mazaunan birnin. Dukansu m cikin soyayya: Catherine sha wahala a cikin iyali Tihona Kabanova da pomolka Larissa da Karandyshev ƙare a bala'i. Bai wanzu ba a yarinya da dangantaka da Paratov: Malkisadik, ko da yake ba ruwanta da ita, same shi da riba ga aure wani gado. Dukansu wadannan tunkaro baƙin ciki, gama m, m da kuma taushi da yanayi shi ya yi yawa nauyi a buga.

A rashin amincewa da patriarchal haruffa

Kowane a cikin nasu rashin amincewa patriarchal Larisa Ogudalova yana kokarin tsayayya da kokarin mahaifiyarsa, Charites Ignatievna m ya aure ta arziki da kuma iko miji. Katerina baro-baro ya furta da kin amincewa da salon cewa ta kaiwa zuwa cikin gidan da mahaifiyarsa-a Kabanova. Ya kamata a lura cewa Katerina mafi decisively da gabagaɗi, bayyana matsayin su, fiye da Larissa: bisa manufa, shi ba zai iya samun zuwa ga sabon halin da ake ciki a wadda ƙare har bayan aure. Mijin ta iyali duk alama m, kuma shi ne har yanzu har zuwa nan a taron da Boris Barbara baro-baro ya furta cewa, kome ta ba cute a cikin mata ta iyali. A zanga-zangar da kuma Larissa fito kawai a lokacin da shi tsanani kwashe Sergeem Sergeevichem Paratovym: mace ba zato ba tsammani bayyana irin halayya da cewa da jũna ba za a iya da ake zargi da wannan ilimi matasa lady. Duk da haka, tuni a farkon replica na heroine karatu zai iya yin hukunci da matakai ƙaddarãwar: ta wajen abruptly yayi magana game da ita da ango Karandyshev da kuma kai tsaye ya gaya masa cewa ya yi hasarar idan aka kwatanta da Paratov.

A halin Larissa

Larisa Ogudalova, sadaki, shi ne alfahari: haka ne, ta ta kunyatar da kansa, da kuma ga mahaifiyarsa, domin squalid hanyar rayuwa da cewa suna da wani sashe, Catering m baƙi suke, jama'a jama'a zuwa ga gidan ganin kyau amma matalauta amarya. Duk da haka, Larisa jure wadannan jam'iyyun, duk da maimaita scandals a cikin gidan, wanda sai ta wãyi gari da aka sani a ko'ina cikin birnin. Duk da haka, a lokacin da ta hankula aka shafa, da heroine raina duk tarurrukan da gudu bayan Paratov ran da ya tashi daga Bryahimova (wanda, ta hanyar, kamar yadda Kalinov, located a kan bankunan na Volga). Bayan ya dawo gida, da heroine ke a zaune ya saba rayuwa, kuma ko da ya amince ya aure Karandyshev - wani unequal aure a madaidaci. Kuma idan ba Paratov hakan a fage, shi ne wata ila don zama Mrs. Larisa Karandyshev zai tafi tare da mijinta a kauyen, da kuma watakila wasu lokaci a gwiwa yanayi zai sami ƙarfin da ci gaba da kai al'ada rayuwa.

A halin Katherine

Duk da haka, irin wannan labari wuya su yi tunanin dangane da Katherine: wuya na karshe su zo sharuddan da irin wannan zama. Faye hali na Larissa Ogudalovoy kamata a kara da cewa heroine ne musamman rufe a kaina, a ta farko da bayyanar a kan mataki, ta yi iyakantacce ne kawai 'yan jawabinsa, yayin da Katherine daga farkon furuci wa' yar'uwarsa Barbara miji. Ta yarda musayarsu da ta yara tunanin, an gane kamar yadda shi ne, ba sauki a cikin sabon yanayi. A wannan haske, shi ya sa hankali kwatanta siffofin da heroines na Tatyanoy Larinoy, da wanda ya, a duban farko, wanda zai iya samun mai yawa a cikin na kowa: duk uku ne daban-daban impulsiveness da spontaneity na ji na kewaye duniya. Duk da haka, Katerina da Larissa ne ma saki daga gaskiya: duka biyu rayuwa kamar a mafarki, kuma ga alama cewa duk lokacin da suke a cikin wasu irin ciki duniya.

Kwatanta Larissa da Catherine

Knurov ba tare da dalili ce cewa a Larissa "kome akwai yau da kullum," ta kama "ether". Wata kila wannan shi ne mafi kyau alama na Larissa Ogudalovoy: ta gaske ne kullum shagala da ya rage mamaki sha'aninsu dabam to duk abin da ke kewaye da shi, da kuma kawai wani lokacin ta karya wasu lura, wadda ba ta distaste ga tausayin-bourgeois rayuwa. Abin mamaki, sai ta ba ta fa soyayya, ko ma a kalla wasu so ga mahaifiyarsa. Lalle ne, haƙĩƙa, daga wani halin kirki ra'ayi hoto na ni'imar Ignatievna nisa daga manufa, amma wannan mace, bayan duk, kula da 'yarta, ta ne da damuwa game da rabo, kuma lalle ne, haƙĩƙa ya cancanci wasu biyayya. Larisa ya burge rabu daga rayuwar matasa lady: ta image, sai su yi magana, incorporeal kuma saki daga tarihi da kuma zamantakewa gona. A wannan girmamawa, Catherine ne mafi idon basira: shi ne rai da kuma kula da abin da ke faruwa kewaye. Ta na zaune a cika a hankali, arziki, ko da yake mafi ban tausayi rayuwa. Duk da haka, da image na Katherine siffofi da wasu idealization, duk da sosai recognizable fasali.

Kwatanta da heroines na Tatyanoy Larinoy

Tatyana Larina ba - shi ne kulla alakar ta da ƙasarsa ta kauye a kusurwa, da kuma yadda labari ya ce Eugene a wasan karshe. Pushkin ta heroine tsaya kyam a kan ta ƙasa, wanda ba shi da halin kirki ƙarfin yin tsayayya auku to da rabo daga gwaji. Wannan shi ne dalilin da ya sa shi ne wani al'amari na girmamawa, da kuma Larissa da Katerina - tausayi da tausayi. Lalle ne shĩ, aiki "Larissa Ogudalova" Ya kamata zana wani layi daya tsakanin ta wasan kwaikwayo, da bala'i Kateriny Kabanovoy Tatyana Larina da kuma tarihi.